Retirement Withdrawal Strategies for Municipal Employee’s

You’ve spent years building your 457(b) savings—now it’s time to create a plan that turns those savings into a secure, tax-efficient retirement income.

Retirement Withdrawal Strategies for 457(b) Accounts: A Guide for Municipal Employees

As a municipal employee when you approach retirement, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by the multitude of financial decisions that lie ahead. You’ve spent years contributing to your 457(b) deferred compensation plan, but now the real question is: how do I make the most of my hard-earned savings?

 

The stakes are high, effective withdrawal management maximizes after-tax dollars while minimizing tax impacts for a comfortable retirement.

 

But navigating these decisions isn’t always straightforward. Between managing taxes, asset allocation, and different withdrawal strategies, retirees face complex choices.

 

Therefore, this guide will help you understand key principles like the 4% rule, asset location, tax-efficient withdrawals, and strategies to make the most of your retirement dollars and after-tax funds.

 

To begin, it’s important to understand the basics of the 457(b) plan and its rules.

 

Common Withdrawal Strategies:

Withdrawal strategies involve more than just pulling an arbitrary dollar amount to cover bills or fund an annual vacation. By applying the right principles, you can optimize your retirement withdrawals, potentially lowering your tax burden and increasing your financial freedom. It’s important to track your expenses and create a financial plan so you aren’t overdrawing from your retirement accounts. With thoughtful planning, it’s possible to make your retirement dollars work harder for you, allowing for a more secure and flexible future.

 

The 4% Rule—a principle derived from the “Trinity Study”—is often cited as a benchmark for sustainable withdrawals in retirement. The rule suggests withdrawing 4% of your retirement savings annually. This is based upon an asset allocation of anywhere between 50-70% equities and the remaining in fixed income or the general account.

 

For example, if you have $500,000 in your 457(b) plan:

  • Year 1 withdrawal: $20,000.
  • Subsequent years: Adjusted slightly upwards for inflation.

But the 4% rule isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution. Factors like market volatility, rising healthcare costs, and life expectancy can impact the sustainability of this approach.

 

Therefore, while the 4% rule is a helpful guideline, you may need to modify it based on your specific circumstances. Especially with municipal workers, there’s a lot more factors to consider. Such as pension payments, retiree healthcare benefits, and social security timing.  A key improvement is to integrate flexible withdrawal strategies based on market performance, ensuring you preserve your portfolio in down markets.  

 

Coordinating Withdrawals Across Accounts

For retirees with multiple accounts—457(b), IRAs, 401(k)s, 457(b) Roth accounts, and taxable brokerage accounts— Integrating the 4% rule with the tax-efficient withdrawals could help to maximize your retirement dollars. Here’s how to approach it:

 

General Rule of Thumb for Tax-Efficient Sequencing:

  • Start with taxable accounts: Using funds from taxable accounts first allows tax-deferred accounts like your 457(b) to continue growing. This also minimizes RMD impacts later. A short-term or long-term holding period will have different tax consequences.
  • Move to tax-deferred accounts (457(b), IRA): Withdraw from these accounts once taxable funds are exhausted or when required by law.
  • Reserve Roth accounts for last**: Roth accounts grow tax-free and are not subject to RMDs, making them ideal for preserving wealth or passing on to heirs.
    • Roth accounts are particularly useful when you have a large, one-time expense. Such as a vacation home, expensive vehicle, or even large home renovations. This is because when taking a qualified withdrawal, it is not added as taxable income. 

Why it works: This approach maximizes the efficiency of your saved dollars. Saving the Roth accounts for last is important because it gives those funds the longest time to grow tax free. However, this depends on your unique financial situation and goals.

 

Well, What Should I Hold In Each Account?

Not all retirement accounts are equal when it comes to asset types. For example:

  • Tax-deferred accounts: Typically hold bond funds, mutual funds, REITs or fixed-income investments. When funds are taken as a withdrawal, they will be taxed at your ordinary income.
  • Taxable accounts: Ideal for stocks or ETFs due to favorable long-term capital gains tax rates. In addition, this is where government and municipal bonds should be held to realize their tax benefits.
  • Roth accounts: Best for high-growth investments, as qualified withdrawals are tax-free.

Why? By withdrawing from accounts based on their tax treatment and asset type, retirees can minimize tax liabilities while maintaining their portfolio’s overall risk balance.

 

Other Strategies to Maximize “Retirement Dollars” and After-Tax Dollars

To get the most out of your savings, consider these additional strategies:

 

Bucket Strategy

Divide your assets into “buckets” based on when you’ll need them. It’s important to have a big picture overview of all of your assets:

  • Short-term bucket: Cash and low-risk investments for expenses in the first 3 years.
  • Mid-term bucket: Moderate-risk investments for years 5–15 of retirement.
  • Long-term bucket: Growth-focused investments for 15+ years.

 

The bucket strategy reduces the risk of selling investments at a loss during market downturns while allowing long-term growth.

 

Roth Conversions

Converting part of your 457(b) plan to a Roth during years of low taxable income (such as early retirement) can lower your tax burden in the long run. However, with municipal employees it’s not uncommon to have a higher income in retirement due to pensions, social security, and other income.

  • Advantages: Funds grow tax-free, and Roth IRAs have no RMDs.
  • Considerations: Pay taxes on the conversion amount upfront, but reap the benefits later.

Delay Social Security

Delaying Social Security benefits past your full retirement age increases your monthly benefit by 8% per year up to age 70. This decision has many more factors than just deciding to wait to collect the extra benefit. It’s important to contact a financial professional that will be able to estimate when taking your social security will be most efficient.

  • Use 457(b) withdrawals to cover expenses in the interim, maximizing your guaranteed lifetime income from Social Security.

Balancing Taxes and Spending: The Big Picture

Understanding the tax implications of your withdrawal strategy is critical to maximizing after-tax dollars. Let’s look at a practical example:

 

Example: Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Timeline for Retirees

  1. Ages 50–65: Using your taxable accounts & pension for living expenses. Roth conversions could be considered depending on your goals. Before retirement, it’s important to ensure that your asset allocation meets your short-term and long-term goals.
  2. Ages 66–70: Generally, most folks begin collecting Social Security while starting or continuing  tax-efficient withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts. Social Security may supplement withdrawals from retirement assets.
  3. Ages 70+: Withdraw RMDs strategically while using Roth accounts for flexibility and estate planning.

Why It Matters for Municipal Employees

Retirement withdrawal strategies aren’t just about managing numbers—they’re about securing your lifestyle in retirement. Municipal employees with deferred compensation accounts face unique challenges, such as balancing pensions with 457(b) accounts, planning for healthcare costs, and accounting for local and state tax rates.

 

But with careful planning, you can maximize every dollar saved, minimize taxes, and achieve peace of mind knowing your retirement is secure.

 

Therefore, if you’re a municipal employee nearing retirement, it’s never too early to start crafting your withdrawal strategy. With a combination of the 4% SafeMax principle, tax-efficient sequencing, and strategic asset management, you can turn your savings into a sustainable income that supports your goals.

 

Tips & Tricks:

Your NYS pension is exempt from state taxes, and the first $20,000 withdrawn annually from your 457(b) account is also state-tax exempt over the age of 59.5. Be sure to review your plan documents to verify this.

 

The Truth

Municipal professionals face unique financial circumstances compared to private-sector employees. Whether you’re a police officer, firefighter, clerical worker, or highway department employee, your financial needs are distinct. Consulting a trusted financial professional can help ensure you’re on track with a sustainable plan.

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message

Schedule A Free Consultation

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly.